Gerson Digital : Denmark

RKD STUDIES

6.4 Morell’s Critical Catalogue (1767)

The contents of this gallery are documented in Morell’s Beurtheilendes Verzeichniß aller in der Neuen Gallerie befindlichen kostbahren Mahlereyen […] (Critical Catalogue of all the Precious Paintings Located in the New Gallery) of 1767. By this time the constellation of individuals responsible for the art collection at the Danish court had changed fundamentally. King Frederick V, who favoured the erection of a gallery, had died in 1766 and in his wake Morell’s mentor, Adam Gottlob Moltke (1710-1792) [1], also fell. The new, mentally unstable King Christian VII (1749-1808) appears to have had no real interest in the art collection. Against this background Morell’s Verzeichnis, in which he expressed gratitude for the royal confidence in him and for his reaffirmation as gallery director, was equally intended to alert the king to the treasures of the gallery as well as to the indispensability of its director. Thus Morell expresses the hope that the king may ‘experience pleasant enjoyment by admiring what is beautiful, noble and elevated’. With this kind of aesthetic vocabulary of the Enlightenment, the gallery director incorporates a reference to his own competence and decisiveness when he speaks of a collection ‘that was made with choice and knowledge, and furnished with order, harmony and taste’. It is these attributes that also apply to the qualitative criteria for a collection and collector in contemporary auction catalogues.1 As an entirely practical gesture to the king, Morell offered to introduce a comparable new arrangement to the Kunstkammer, the director of which, Wahl, had already died in 1765, as well as to inspect the holdings of paintings of Frederiksborg Castle.

The ‘critical catalogue’ documents the state of the gallery as Morell had conceived and installed it. At the same time each artist is classified art-historically, with each painting described with respect to its provenance, its meaning in the oeuvre, or it place on the art market. As this was not a commemorative record of the Danish Royal house, only portraits of exceptional artistic quality came to be exhibited. Dutch and Flemish paintings were greatly in the majority, interestingly with histories outnumbering genre paintings and still lifes (see Table 1 and 2).

As the acquisitions for the Kunstkammer with respect to Morell are well documented, one can in great part identify the exhibited pieces. It should be said that many of the paintings in the new gallery had come to Copenhagen in the 1750s; on the one hand they belonged to those that Morell had sold to the Kunstkammer from Hamburg in 1755; on the other they were paintings which Morell – already having a picture gallery in mind – had purchased in the Low Countries in 1759. At issue are mainly Dutch and Flemish cabinet paintings of the kind that also featured in the collection of Minister Moltke.2 Perhaps one can even discern two competing collections as conceived by Morell. That could explain that Morell preferred expensive histories as well as Flemish still lifes and animal paintings to the more affordable landscapes. To the former genre belong, for instance, the Sea Battle by Bakhuizen (800rd.), a hunting still life by each of Dirk Valkenburg and Jan Weenix (400 and 300rd. Respectively [2-3]), a Poultry Yard by Melchior d’Hondercoeter (300rd.), a Fruit and Flower Still Life by Joris van Son (300rd.), a Kitchen Scene by Frans Snijders (200rd.) [4] and a Crowning with Thorns by Hendrick ter Brugghen (300rd., purchased as Honthorst) [5].3

1
Georg Wilhelm Bauernfeind after Carl Gustav Pilo
Portrait of Adam Gottlob Moltke (1710-1792), dated 1757
paper ? x ? mm
lower right : G.W. Baurenfeind fec. Chalcogr. Hafnia
Copenhagen, SMK - The Royal Collection of Graphic Art, inv./cat.nr. KK 3961 / 422

#


2
Dirk Valkenburg
Still life of game and fruit in a park
canvas, oil paint 140 x 191 cm
lower right : J. Wenincx
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp621

3
Jan Weenix
Hunting still life in a formal garden, dated 1701
canvas, oil paint 148 x 130,5 cm
center right : J. Weenix f / 1701
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp621


4
Frans Snijders or studio of Frans Snijders
Still life with fruit on a table, first half of the 1620s
canvas, oil paint 118,5 x 177,5 cm
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp209

5
Hendrick ter Brugghen
The crowning with thorns, dated 1620
canvas, oil paint 207 x 240 cm
lower left : HTBrugghen / fecit 1620
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp365


Of the acquisitions of 1759, the portraits by Ferdinand Bol (25rd.), Bartholomeus van der Helst (28rd.) [6], Michiel van Mierevelt (20rd., now Pickenoy), Rembrandt’s Christ and the Disciples on the Road to Emmaus (75rd.), Ferdinand Bol’s Easter Morning (180rd.) [7], Adriaen van Nieulandt’s Entry into Jerusalem (100rd.) [8], Castiglione‘s Rebecca at the Well (65rd.), Roos’ Bull Fight (250rd.), Zacharias Webber‘s Allegory on the Sciences (100rd.) [9], landscapes by Jan Hackaert (65rd.), Wouwermans (64rd.) and Van der Does’ (20rd.) as well as a battle piece by Jan van Huchtenburg (100rd.) [10] all found a place on the walls. Of the artistically important acquisitions of 1763, only an Italian Landscape by Horatius de Hooch (50rd.) [11] and a Northern Landscape by Allaert van Everdingen (60rd.) were considered. The large Italian works of the Valenti collection appeared to challenge the character of the cabinet.

6
Bartholomeus van der Helst
Portrait of a man sitting on hardbacked chair, c. 1659
canvas, oil paint 97 x 78 cm
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark


7
Ferdinand Bol
The three Mary's at the empty tomb, dated1644
canvas, oil paint 280 x 358 mm
lower right : f.Bol fecit 1644
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMS sp 427

8
Adriaen van Nieulandt
Christ's triumphal entry in Jerusalem, dated 1655
panel, oil paint 85,5 x 114 cm
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark


9
Zacharias Webber (II)
Allegory on Apollo as patron of the arts and artists, dated 1672
canvas, oil paint 191 x 163 cm
center : Z:Webber Fecit 1672
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark

10
Jan van Huchtenburg
An equestrian battle scene
canvas, oil paint 113 x 155 cm
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp634


As part of the way pictures were hung, paintings by Roos, Ter Brugghen and Bol came to be juxtaposed with works that were already in the Kunstkammer, such as the pictures by Jacob Jordaens (after Ovid) [12], with an Allegory by Pietro Liberi as well as a Wedding of Alexander and Roxane by Gerard de Lairesse [13] at the middle. The same role was served on the side walls by the Kitchen still lifes by Frans Snijders [14].

Morell leaves us in the dark with regard to what motivated him to select precisely these works for the gallery. Authentication of his claim to a connoisseur’s ability to differentiate between original and copy may have been one criteria; and indeed, most of Morell’s proposed attributions for the new gallery hold to this day. Justification for the high prices at the sales of 1755 may also have played a role. It also appears to have been important for Morell to convey a representative overview of the Dutch and Flemish painters, with their characteristic masterpieces. In the process he largely repeats the body of artists uncovered by Houbraken and passed on by Jean Baptiste Descamps, although he is more inclined to be critical of details. For instance, he notes that because of the ‘negligence of Houbraken’, the teacher and year of death of Johannes Lingelbach are not known. In the case of Mierevelt he relegates the 5,000 paintings that the artist is said to have done by Houbraken, along with Descamps’ 10,000, to the land of fables. On the other hand he agrees with Descamps’ assessment of the worth of Bartholomeus van der Helst.4

11
Horatius de Hooch
Italianate landscape with travelers near a ruin, dated 1652
canvas, oil paint 100,5 x 151,5 cm
lower right : HD Hooch 1652
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp315

12
Jacob Jordaens (I)
The apotheosis of Aeneas (Ovid, Met.XIV, 581-608)), c. 1617
canvas, oil paint 212,5 x 236 cm
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMS1310a

13
Gerard de Lairesse
Marriage of Alexander and Roxana, dated 1664
canvas, oil paint 79 x 89,5 cm
lower left : ANº1664 Gerardus Larissus inventor fecit
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp306

14
Frans Snijders
Kitchen scene with game and vegetables, with a serving boy holding a plate with the head of a boar, c. 1616-1618
canvas, oil paint 123,2 x 239,7 cm
lower center : F. Snyders. fecit
Copenhagen, SMK - National Gallery of Denmark, inv./cat.nr. KMSsp208


Notes

1 According to Zelle 2002 .

2 See § 6.5.

3 The Bakhuizen, Hondecoeter and the two Van Sons are illustrated in § 6.2.

4 See § 6.2.

Cookies disclaimer

I agree Our site saves small pieces of text information (cookies) on your device in order to deliver better content and for statistical purposes. You can disable the usage of cookies by changing the settings of your browser. By browsing our website without changing the browser settings you grant us permission to store that information on your device.